NYCThirst

Cookies

A LITTLE ABOUT Cookies

Cookies greets you with a cursive sign above the door that gives off just the right mix of elegance and mystery. The large windows offer just enough of a glimpse inside to make it feel a little speakeasy-adjacent—inviting, but not shouting for attention. Step inside, and you're instantly transported... somewhere. It’s hard to say exactly where or when, but it’s definitely not just another neighborhood bar.

The first thing that catches your eye are two rustic booths, each with tabletops covered in whimsical floral wallpaper. Anywhere else, it might look like a design accident. Here, though, it works—like they’ve mastered the art of controlled chaos. The bar itself is built from sturdy construction beams, paired with vinyl stools dressed in vintage floral patterns. It all combines into a kind of charming, lived-in eclecticism that’s oddly comforting.

At first glance, the space feels intimate, even small. But make your way toward the back, and you’ll stumble across a tucked-away seating alcove that feels like a hidden lounge. Keep going and you’ll find an unmarked door that opens to a surprisingly large backyard—complete with a ping pong table. It’s the kind of place that slowly reveals itself, like a good book you didn’t know you were about to love.

The backyard continues the bar’s offbeat style. There are four large benches that comfortably seat six, and a white wooden canopy that adds a little polish without feeling fussy. The seating is a mix of weathered wood and what can only be described as “stadium-chic.” Whether you're chatting under the stars or arguing about ping pong rules, it's the kind of setup that makes a casual night out linger longer than planned.

Cookies may not flaunt itself, but it knows what it’s doing. With events like Guinness happy hour, oyster days, and even arts and crafts nights, there’s always a reason to return. Just remember—it’s cash only, and trust me, you’ll want to stay for more than one round. Bring cash, bring friends, and maybe don’t tell everyone about it. Some secrets are worth keeping.